OpenBao v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4 build trail

How ReadyStack built readystack/openbao:v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4 and its build kit, copied record by record: why the release exists, every chain, drive and stage it went through, the model work, the review rounds, the defects, the checks that verified it and when it was published. Each line names the record it comes from in brackets; a record that does not exist for this release says so.

This trail

As JSON
  • Imagereadystack/openbao:v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4
  • Index digestsha256:0da03bca01630f3a873f872b439d3b85384ac032b25eb6208163b811f0c91a4e
  • linux/amd64 digestsha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8
  • ArchiveReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz
  • Archive SHA-256 now4dcc4fb171a58d320dcfcb75a35385adfc13ec4430c47295c21355a340adfa67
  • Pins recorddocs/PINS.md, docs/provenance/PINS.json in the archive (since generated)
  • Generated2026-11-17T10:13:19Z by KitForge release/build_trail.py
  • Sections9 sections, 8 fully recorded; 1 item not recorded

Signed with the release key The trail's signature is a Sigstore bundle beside it. Check it is ours before you rely on it:

cosign verify-blob --key https://readystack.dev/keys/cosign.pub \
  --bundle ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.trail.json.sigstore ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.trail.json

IdentityWhy this release existsThe path through the harnessModel work per stageReviewDefectsVerificationPublicationPackages and CPU level

Identity

Fully recorded
  • ProductOpenBao (openbao) [MANIFEST.json]
  • Release tagv2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4 [MANIFEST.json]
  • Imagereadystack/openbao:v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4 [MANIFEST.json]
  • Image index digestsha256:0da03bca01630f3a873f872b439d3b85384ac032b25eb6208163b811f0c91a4e [docs/provenance/LOCKED_DIGEST.txt]
  • linux/amd64 image digestsha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8 [ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.json, subject.image_manifest_digest]
  • ArchiveReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz (bytes 554934973) [MANIFEST.json]
  • Archive sha256 at publish4dcc4fb171a58d320dcfcb75a35385adfc13ec4430c47295c21355a340adfa67 [MANIFEST.json, tarball_sha256]
  • Archive records agreeyes [MANIFEST.json, PUBLISH_MANIFEST.json and .cutover.json name the same sha256]
  • Repack historynone: the archive is as first published [MANIFEST.json, repack_history]
  • Upstream repositoryhttps://github.com/openbao/openbao [docs/provenance/SOURCE_TREE_HASH.json]
  • Upstream refv2.7.2 [docs/provenance/SOURCE_TREE_HASH.json]
  • Upstream commit9e0a0d3c3504a0a00b45e61355afac5e35c78379 [docs/provenance/SOURCE_TREE_HASH.json]
  • Source tree hash39ce90cd211893e1a0f3ef5a1a0ae7df0badaab1b54fd79b9da5b3e7b174369d (files 5401) [docs/provenance/SOURCE_TREE_HASH.json, tree_listing_sha256 (sha256 of the sorted file listing)]
  • Kit tree hashsha256:e04137429dc85d8333afd2eee84dc5a13a902cdf3c7e1bbac3bab5c4dc9c17c7 [ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.json, inputs.tree_hash]
  • SOURCE_DATE_EPOCH1793043147 (utc 2026-10-26T19:32:27Z) [ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.json, inputs.source_date_epoch]
  • Base images
    • ref golang:1.27.4-bookworm@sha256:4fa7c968ba93f1635670522dbb01a2c78150443e1385746924566079f36570ea · platform digest sha256:fb7cceb528b47141eccd9b60bf3cbd27d5ef5f8cf5b7d338bec866da495b50dc
    • ref ubuntu:24.04@sha256:2198e4c65076e9cb0b3d695219df667c0e3b0072da64ca3c2648aca17dcecaf5 · platform digest sha256:77eb101c607d6e3d4f5ad0c8a02c2136c689b98aba1f359e6502ba517e5c57ec
    [ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.json, bases]
  • BuildKitmoby/buildkit:v0.31.2 (image digest sha256:e0e67ea9c4bb07bdef683e29f70f3b623d1eb9c82274a9ec04e6bb0511449fb0) [ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.json, engine]
  • Engine commit(s)
    • commit 29bfdab1610e0f8b1544b1f8694e276b9c10f534 · dirty yes · first drive 4071
    • commit b573f37eea6c59511fd1e8393c27f35fb8588cf0 · dirty yes · first drive 4117
    • commit 589a5a5d2a8f3f57fa5368385501ae1bd7143530 · dirty yes · first drive 4132
    • commit 8f330f31aa066ed1381d543d473df5415ecba80a · dirty yes · first drive 4167
    • commit 54655941a57a669c75e2d14cb2734b5d7d8cddac · dirty yes · first drive 4197
    • commit d53b685426c75d2ba6e44854aa04462d4677700c · dirty yes · first drive 4207
    • commit 1e12108047d40ec72e593f39c24455ea312ddb43 · dirty yes · first drive 4219
    • commit 8c06307911557c927272aed1342f4fd649c279f0 · dirty yes · first drive 4229
    • commit e06c8c0d4f40771692abda70ebb80df73b0cbb40 · dirty yes · first drive 4239
    • commit 467eb57e7940ba12684129fd11ece63592f7796d · dirty yes · first drive 4244
    • commit 5f4521e0d2df5adb38871ef955a44c26665073d0 · dirty yes · first drive 4252
    • commit 7f59566f2ae65f85cbb2d38b9576654acd74c34e · dirty yes · first drive 4274
    • commit 4c774a01707ad40318172ca6b740daa8f9500922 · dirty yes · first drive 4278
    • commit d62bc307b80fc9de83cfffe5b1725e304f54a5af · dirty yes · first drive 4281
    • commit 0f21a2ab03d2b97a51c73491893df1ff5fee29e1 · dirty yes · first drive 4293
    • commit a09bd1cdda98a0fdbed6236e2bb209da3e6cc509 · dirty yes · first drive 4320
    • commit b3c5568cae9b84968afbee651687d74459ff409a · dirty yes · first drive 4325
    • commit bc58aeba5e54c10417ad8d63e707fff94089dd1e · dirty yes · first drive 4361
    • commit c8155eab7005e164326d14c384d473b047cfc227 · dirty yes · first drive 4396
    • commit d7c629c61d3d1905f2f4aff5c1a3ebd1d543891a · dirty yes · first drive 4448
    • commit a8f9a7a13a5afbd6dd0df0a91e7d0fbee76954b4 · dirty yes · first drive 4495
    • commit 53328f4754ecefc18b308504e3b02f89c9062497 · dirty yes · first drive 4557
    • commit 7e5e859529535df572f4abd7beb5734967bb5f63 · dirty yes · first drive 4656
    • commit 3a92ccf595e022be5e95e5ae873bf920a2695ed4 · dirty yes · first drive 4690
    • commit 5ce9272390ca24d73f15fbd01c2004057d1e84fb · dirty yes · first drive 4753
    • commit e3059a86a8e834c23da2167b18f6c0b5a2f6d776 · dirty yes · first drive 4763
    [drive_runs, engine_sha]

Why this release exists

Fully recorded
  • Chain931 (created 2026-11-09T16:19:48Z · trigger customer_request · upstream version v2.7.2) [chains, chains #931]
  • Requestbuild request #606 (rebuild) (requested at 2026-11-09T07:47:32Z · requested by kitforge-agent · version v2.7.2) [build_requests, build_requests #606]
  • Reasonrevision v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4: same upstream version rebuilt on a chiselled Ubuntu 24.04 runtime (retarget.py --rev-bump; PR #292) [build_requests, build_requests #606 request_reason]
  • Supersedesreadystack/openbao:v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r3 (chain 839) [chains, chains #839]

The path through the harness

Fully recorded

1 chain · 26 drives · 18 stages · 7 rewinds

Chain 931 release · ready_to_ship

Created 2026-11-09T16:19:48Z, upstream v2.7.2, build request 606 [chains, chains #931]

DriveStartedMinutesBuild hostHow it stopped
40712026-11-09T16:20:16Z196build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check exists:checksums; 18 ticks [drive_runs, drive_runs #4071]
41172026-11-09T22:11:23Z19.3build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check exists:checksums; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4117]
41322026-11-09T23:13:22Z10.9build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check exists:checksums; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4132]
41672026-11-10T08:42:43Z10.7build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check exists:checksums; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4167]
41972026-11-10T22:05:48Z9.5build host 5 withhold-publish ready_to_ship at package_archive; 2 ticks [drive_runs, drive_runs #4197]
42072026-11-10T22:55:50Z4.3build host 5 withhold-publish ready_to_ship at package_archive; 2 ticks [drive_runs, drive_runs #4207]
42192026-11-10T23:42:23Z1.4build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4219]
42292026-11-11T00:22:04Z1.5build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4229]
42392026-11-11T01:25:58Z1.4build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4239]
42442026-11-11T03:12:25Z4.1build host 5 withhold-publish ready_to_ship at package_archive; 2 ticks [drive_runs, drive_runs #4244]
42522026-11-11T03:49:07Z6.2build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4252]
42742026-11-11T08:12:56Z4.4build host 5 withhold-publish ready_to_ship at package_archive; 2 ticks [drive_runs, drive_runs #4274]
42782026-11-11T08:53:20Z6.3build host 5 withhold-publish ready_to_ship at package_archive; 2 ticks [drive_runs, drive_runs #4278]
42812026-11-11T09:21:54Z3build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4281]
42932026-11-11T20:15:32Z3.5build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4293]
43202026-11-11T23:12:17Z2.8build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4320]
43252026-11-11T23:56:24Z2.8build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4325]
43612026-11-12T06:33:57Z3.4build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4361]
43962026-11-12T10:08:05Z2.7build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4396]
44482026-11-12T15:25:14Z3.9build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4448]
44952026-11-12T22:34:37Z3.3build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4495]
45572026-11-13T10:36:58Z3.2build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4557]
46562026-11-14T08:22:27Z3.3build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4656]
46902026-11-17T02:46:31Z4.9build host 5 withhold-publish stage_failed at package_archive; first failed check g8; 1 tick [drive_runs, drive_runs #4690]
47532026-11-17T09:19:19Z28.6build host 5 withhold-publish ready_to_ship at package_archive; 16 ticks [drive_runs, drive_runs #4753]
47632026-11-17T10:06:50Z—build host 5 publish-held not recorded [drive_runs, drive_runs #4763]

Stages, in order

StageFirst startPassedAttemptsGate checks passedArtifacts (SHA-256)
intake 2026-11-09T16:20:28Z2026-11-09T16:20:30Z1
4
  • exists:order_json
  • order_json:json_parses
  • order_json:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • produces_paths_exist
order_json 98e3aba9c427…
acquire 2026-11-09T16:21:37Z2026-11-09T16:21:39Z1
12
  • exists:source_tree
  • exists:source_tree_hash
  • exists:source_file_manifest
  • exists:custody_inputs
  • exists:license_file
  • source_tree:dir_nonempty
  • source_tree_hash:json_parses
  • source_file_manifest:json_parses
  • custody_inputs:json_parses
  • license_file:file_nonempty
  • produces_paths_exist
  • custody_inputs:json_true:ce_audit.ce_only
source_tree 21ea52d19af8…
license_file d6b1a865f1c8…
custody_inputs 47e5993b84e8…
source_tree_hash 521b712bd4b3…
source_file_manifest 25a3ce4f41e0…
plan 2026-11-09T16:22:14Z2026-11-09T16:22:15Z1
10
  • exists:recon_report
  • exists:input_pin_plan
  • exists:toolchain_lock
  • recon_report:md_min_sections:3
  • recon_report:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • input_pin_plan:md_min_sections:2
  • input_pin_plan:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • toolchain_lock:file_nonempty
  • toolchain_lock:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • produces_paths_exist
recon_report 0bc206c5e61c…
input_pin_plan 17ee31d8e215…
toolchain_lock d2c422a678f5…
assemble_kit 2026-11-09T16:29:15Z2026-11-17T09:26:00Z2
27
  • exists:dockerfile
  • exists:base_image_digests
  • exists:system_pinning
  • exists:build_recipe
  • exists:first_build_digest
  • exists:first_boot_health
  • exists:dockerfile_offline
  • exists:verify_offline_sh
  • exists:build_offline_sh
  • exists:generate_sbom_sh
  • dockerfile:file_nonempty
  • dockerfile:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • base_image_digests:file_nonempty
  • system_pinning:file_nonempty
  • build_recipe:json_parses
  • first_build_digest:file_nonempty
  • first_boot_health:file_nonempty
  • dockerfile_offline:file_nonempty
  • dockerfile_offline:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • verify_offline_sh:file_nonempty
  • verify_offline_sh:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • build_offline_sh:file_nonempty
  • build_offline_sh:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • generate_sbom_sh:file_nonempty
  • generate_sbom_sh:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • produces_paths_exist
  • first_boot_health:file_contains:healthy=True
dockerfile 89603af91838…
build_recipe 9da13c9267ec…
system_pinning aa8db05a9a8a…
build_offline_sh 6ab4f08a6ec7…
generate_sbom_sh ce0f1e6f1e70…
first_boot_health bf516eb5ef24…
verify_offline_sh 3e8184ea230c…
base_image_digests 5b3481a0c1a9…
dockerfile_offline 89603af91838…
first_build_digest 597c24155ba2…
remediate 2026-11-09T16:29:54Z2026-11-17T09:26:05Z2
8
  • exists:vendored_apt
  • exists:remediation_log
  • exists:security_report
  • vendored_apt:dir_exists
  • remediation_log:json_parses
  • security_report:md_min_sections:2
  • security_report:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • produces_paths_exist
vendored_apt e3b0c44298fc…
remediation_log 094653d66f50…
security_report 64d7e96adc66…
build_kit 2026-11-09T16:39:20Z2026-11-17T09:35:53Z2
9
  • exists:freeze_manifest
  • exists:locked_digest
  • exists:cosign_stamp
  • exists:offline_rebuild_transcript
  • freeze_manifest:json_parses
  • locked_digest:file_nonempty
  • cosign_stamp:file_nonempty
  • offline_rebuild_transcript:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
cosign_stamp aa428f0b93bb…
locked_digest 30bb53987bbb…
freeze_manifest 449285a460c3…
offline_rebuild_transcript 360758e40e1d…
verdict 2026-11-09T16:40:11Z2026-11-17T09:36:42Z2
8
  • exists:scout_verdict
  • scout_verdict:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
  • scout_verdict:release_check_passed
  • scout_verdict:nonroot_green
  • scout_verdict:zero_fixable_crit_high
  • scout_verdict:osv_clean
  • scout_verdict:no_baked_secrets
scout_verdict 2305d8b232f6…
publish_image 2026-11-09T16:40:47Z2026-11-17T09:37:23Z2
7
  • exists:promotion_record
  • exists:hub_readme
  • promotion_record:json_parses
  • hub_readme:md_min_sections:2
  • hub_readme:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • produces_paths_exist
  • promotion_record:json_true:signed
hub_readme 44e4c19f7d5a…
promotion_record 8a9ef248288d…
boot_instance 2026-11-09T16:40:53Z2026-11-17T09:37:36Z4
3
  • exists:instance_handle
  • instance_handle:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
instance_handle 3010c9e96318…
sbom 2026-11-09T16:41:15Z2026-11-17T09:37:52Z2
5
  • exists:sbom_json
  • exists:sbom_md
  • sbom_json:json_parses
  • sbom_md:md_min_sections:1
  • produces_paths_exist
sbom_md c5b9ba4ef675…
sbom_json 7af59a1a40bd…
schema_discovery 2026-11-09T16:41:19Z2026-11-17T09:37:55Z2
7
  • exists:dependency_tree
  • exists:table_classification
  • exists:schema_hash
  • dependency_tree:json_parses
  • table_classification:json_parses
  • schema_hash:file_nonempty
  • produces_paths_exist
schema_hash c4f76a2d67f7…
dependency_tree cf4402a7cbf9…
table_classification f06a3a0d62eb…
admin_handbook 2026-11-09T17:18:20Z2026-11-17T09:38:04Z2
7
  • exists:admin_handbook
  • exists:api_map
  • admin_handbook:md_min_sections:10
  • admin_handbook:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • api_map:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
  • admin_handbook:command_transcripts_clean
api_map 5648d1d8a7e7…
admin_handbook eb76c0a7151d…
db_handbook 2026-11-09T17:43:52Z2026-11-17T09:38:16Z2
8
  • exists:db_handbook
  • exists:seed_isolation
  • db_handbook:md_min_sections:5
  • db_handbook:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • seed_isolation:md_min_sections:1
  • seed_isolation:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • produces_paths_exist
  • db_handbook:command_transcripts_clean
db_handbook 6f753a168cbb…
seed_isolation 4b61342c9275…
seed_data 2026-11-09T17:44:04Z2026-11-17T09:38:25Z2
6
  • exists:seed_data_sql
  • exists:seed_cases_json
  • seed_data_sql:sql_parses
  • seed_data_sql:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • seed_cases_json:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
seed_data_sql 9f7a4879cb63…
seed_cases_json 6e6cb579df60…
seed_validate 2026-11-09T17:44:07Z2026-11-17T09:38:28Z2
3
  • exists:seed_data_contract
  • seed_data_contract:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
seed_data_contract 81ba84bbb60b…
usecase_validate 2026-11-09T17:44:26Z2026-11-17T09:38:41Z2
10
  • exists:usecase_contract
  • exists:passed_tests
  • exists:failed_tests
  • exists:test_results
  • usecase_contract:json_parses
  • passed_tests:md_min_sections:1
  • failed_tests:md_min_sections:1
  • test_results:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
  • test_results:usecase_thresholds:80,70
failed_tests b2247b16f5f7…
passed_tests aeca1aa1e3f9…
test_results ca8f56a80f26…
usecase_contract f2c31b3855b2…
finalize_docs 2026-11-09T18:13:18Z2026-11-17T09:38:48Z2
9
  • exists:api_integration_guide
  • exists:release_notes
  • exists:defects_json
  • api_integration_guide:md_min_sections:3
  • api_integration_guide:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • release_notes:md_min_sections:3
  • release_notes:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • defects_json:json_parses
  • produces_paths_exist
defects_json a0dd6c9b833e…
release_notes af393a06c52b…
api_integration_guide 2d049197dde8…
package_archive invalidated 2026-11-17T10:06:20Z 2026-11-09T19:36:14Z2026-11-17T09:47:56Z25
37 (final gate PASS)
  • exists:checksums
  • exists:verify_md
  • exists:rebuild_md
  • exists:provenance_md
  • exists:manifest_txt
  • exists:assetchain_log_md
  • exists:assetchain_log_json
  • exists:actions_jsonl
  • exists:sale_tar
  • checksums:file_nonempty
  • verify_md:md_min_sections:2
  • verify_md:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • rebuild_md:md_min_sections:2
  • rebuild_md:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • provenance_md:md_min_sections:2
  • provenance_md:no_forbidden_placeholders
  • manifest_txt:file_nonempty
  • assetchain_log_md:md_min_sections:1
  • assetchain_log_json:json_parses
  • actions_jsonl:file_nonempty
  • sale_tar:file_nonempty
  • produces_paths_exist
  • G8 cosign
  • G8 scan_grade
  • G8 tag_base_os
  • G8 thread_exit
  • G8 vex_shipped
  • G8 cpu_baseline
  • G8 unpack_files
  • G8 scout_grade_a
  • G8 script_copies
  • G8 upgrade_check
  • G8 offline_rebuild
  • G8 rebuild_manifest
  • G8 artifact_coverage
  • G8 trademark_shipped
  • G8 assetchain_coverage
sale_tar b9e70b9beb72…
checksums 1eb640d299a6…
verify_md 587921e71eb2…
rebuild_md 0666b55a2f9a…
manifest_txt 0b1a7b3110bd…
actions_jsonl 41c42a00c87b…
provenance_md 6c5da6462617…
assetchain_log_md e9eccaec0c0f…
assetchain_log_json b6bfdd0b0983…

[stage_runs]

Rewinds

  • 2026-11-10T22:51:24Z: package_archive to package_archive on docs_redo (scripts/redo-docs.py --stage package_archive) [stage_events, stage_events #30885]
  • 2026-11-10T23:41:37Z: package_archive to package_archive on docs_redo (scripts/redo-docs.py --stage package_archive) [stage_events, stage_events #30934]
  • 2026-11-11T03:47:45Z: package_archive to package_archive on docs_redo (scripts/redo-docs.py --stage package_archive) [stage_events, stage_events #31113]
  • 2026-11-11T08:52:05Z: package_archive to package_archive on docs_redo (scripts/redo-docs.py --stage package_archive) [stage_events, stage_events #31455]
  • 2026-11-11T09:20:34Z: package_archive to package_archive on docs_redo (scripts/redo-docs.py --stage package_archive) [stage_events, stage_events #31495]
  • 2026-11-17T09:19:23Z: package_archive to assemble_kit on strategy_changed (strategy changed (9f62c2ab0bc1 -> d1672f7f1db4)) [stage_events, stage_events #38289]
  • 2026-11-17T10:06:20Z: package_archive to package_archive on docs_redo (scripts/redo-docs.py --stage package_archive) [stage_events, stage_events #38376]

Model work per stage

Fully recorded

Role: writer model. Calls up to 2026-11-17T09:47:56Z.

814 calls over 6 stages

StageCallsRefusedErrorsMax attemptForced commitsReal tokensLesson rules shown
plan2001 07789 —
remediate2001 011005 L-A08, L-038, L-036, L-034, L-032
admin_handbook35821103 935435373 —
db_handbook24613803 623424032 —
usecase_validate1001 01643 —
finalize_docs20511003 452755668 —

[micro_step_runs] [lesson_recalls]

Review

Fully recorded

Role: review model.

6 rounds, 6 counted, $15.48 recorded cost

RoundStartedCriticalMajorMinorVerdictCostCap in forceArchive reviewed
12026-11-10T22:15:51Z 187 findings to repackage [held_rounds, held_rounds #1704] $2.42 3 rounds, $40.00 6f567f19af86…
22026-11-10T23:00:45Z 12238 findings to repackage [held_rounds, held_rounds #1712] $5.26 3 rounds, $40.00 b52c2569b6bf…
32026-11-11T03:17:04Z 0211 findings to repackage [held_rounds, held_rounds #1728] $2.44 3 rounds, $40.00 bbc4c621da18…
42026-11-11T08:17:59Z 0319 findings to repackage [held_rounds, held_rounds #1742] $3.51 3 rounds, $40.00 d36e1b2ab68f…
52026-11-11T09:00:14Z 003 clean to repackage [held_rounds, held_rounds #1743] $1.29 3 rounds, $40.00 dc22e223e16e…
62026-11-17T09:49:16Z 000 clean to publish [held_rounds, held_rounds #1945] $0.56 3 rounds, $40.00 b9e70b9beb72…

Defects

Fully recorded
  • Ledger entries112 [defects, defects where product_slug=openbao and this tag or chain]
  • Disclosed in the archive112 [docs/defects/defects.json, entries]

112 ledger entries: by severity critical 2, high 32, low 78; by status fixed-before-release 112.

DefectSeverityStatusFound byFixed in
RSD-openbao-adb1373522
Admin handbook: The documented volume-ownership fix for the uid-999 upgrade path runs as the non-root openbao user and fails; the customer stays stuck with 'open /openbao/data/vault.db: permission denied'. [defects, defects #233712]
criticalfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-d033e9e8d9
Admin handbook: Says a token with the default policy can drive root-token generation; it gets HTTP 403 at every step; contradicts the API guide and DB handbook. [defects, defects #233713]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-4466b466dc
API guide: Says generate-root needs 'the default policy'; a default-policy-only token is refused with 403; contradicts lines 1709, 1803, 4407. [defects, defects #233714]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-6682623e3d
API guide: Says PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/attempt requires a valid token with the default policy; the endpoint needs no token and is disabled (405) by default. [defects, defects #233715]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-f9b3fb6c61
API guide: 'bao sys/mounts' is not a bao subcommand; the example prints the usage text and fails. [defects, defects #233716]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-6fc5bde699
API guide: Tells the customer to read a KV v2 secret with PUT; PUT is the write method and fails with 400 (and would overwrite if a body were sent). [defects, defects #233717]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-a2288beebc
API guide: The read example uses PUT. [defects, defects #233718]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-566d7f0ff1
API guide: The read-a-specific-version example uses PUT. [defects, defects #233719]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-5828f21c98
API guide: A policy covering sys/mounts/* does not allow listing mounts; the request returns 403. [defects, defects #233720]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-bc6c2e11dc
Admin handbook: The URL given as 'the health endpoint' is followed by 'answers 501/503', which is false for that URL (it answers 200 in all states); contradicts lines 790, 935. [defects, defects #233721]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-0f667e3cbd
Database handbook: Root token length is 26 characters, not 24. [defects, defects #233722]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-0c899c873c
Admin handbook: Claims audit entries may appear in docker logs; they do not. [defects, defects #233723]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-63f564eecf
Admin handbook: Prose says create a new volume, commands delete the old one; contradicts DB handbook 'Lost Unseal Keys'. [defects, defects #233724]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-e5aff2ff26
Admin handbook: 'With any valid token' contradicts the note at line 3907 and the measured 403. [defects, defects #233725]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-7f47d6ea97
API guide: 'any valid token that can authenticate' is wrong for a default-policy token. [defects, defects #233726]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-710f37551c
Admin handbook: The shell example omits -it, so it does not open an interactive shell. [defects, defects #233727]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-26dd14a381
Database handbook: The first documented uid-999 upgrade ownership fix in the DB handbook runs chown on the volume name as a host path and fails, leaving the customer on 'vault.db: permission denied' (the round-1… [defects, defects #236209]
criticalfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-b2f5b0f8b2
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236210]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-7d4f81ecc3
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236211]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-6ca83691f4
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236212]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-269e4aaffd
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236213]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-7df2e6861a
API guide: Says the PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a token (implying a token-based version at that path); with a token they still answer 405. [defects, defects #236214]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-a995cfaf7c
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236215]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-64e82e1073
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236216]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-74b3cc7921
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236217]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-b5e7f862bb
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236218]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-2079c2122b
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236219]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-00a328b412
API guide: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236220]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-9d804b61b7
Database handbook: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236221]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-a58c244882
Database handbook: Says the legacy endpoints are 'authenticated' when disabled (the default); they answer 405 with or without a token. [defects, defects #236222]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-9da8063e6c
Database handbook: States that the legacy PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/* endpoints require a valid token; they need no token and answer 405 unless disable_unauthed_generate_root_endpoints=false (a token does not help). [defects, defects #236223]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-8d6c8fea94
Admin handbook: The example sed command fails with a sed syntax error and edits a configuration key (audit_log_path) that does not exist. [defects, defects #236224]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-f2ec3b05be
Admin handbook: The example configuration puts cluster_addr inside the storage "raft" stanza; a server started with it exits with 'cluster address must be set when using raft storage'. [defects, defects #236225]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-cf409b0551
API guide: The 'must be present' listener example puts cluster_addr inside the listener stanza; a server started with it exits with 'cluster address must be set when using raft storage'. [defects, defects #236226]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-1fd30201e3
API guide: The final decode step of token-based root recovery uses -decode without a value; the command fails with 'Missing otp'. [defects, defects #236227]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-ff0aebc444
API guide: The decode command in the 'Root Token Recovery Using Tokens' block fails with 'Missing otp'. [defects, defects #236228]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-49e8837f75
API guide: Tells the customer they need not unseal after restarting with an edited mounted file; the server is sealed after any restart. [defects, defects #236229]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-551350f301
Admin handbook: The uid-999 ownership fix in the 'Data Volume and Storage' section is given without sudo (or the docker-run form) and fails for a non-root host user, the round-1 critical's class. [defects, defects #236230]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-73a1604d08
API guide: Says the plain health endpoint answers 200 in every server state. [defects, defects #236231]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-d3de82b064
API guide: Says the plain health endpoint answers 200 in all server states. [defects, defects #236232]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-b977661a14
API guide: Says the plain health endpoint returns 200 in all server states. [defects, defects #236233]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-bc2dd09ee5
Database handbook: Says the plain health endpoint always returns 200. [defects, defects #236234]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-544b6b5f80
Admin handbook: Says both token-less endpoints always return 200; the health endpoint answers 501/503. [defects, defects #236235]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-ae9bf2fa4a
Admin handbook: Omits the 501 (uninitialized) answer of the health endpoint. [defects, defects #236236]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-f74e9b9ddd
Admin handbook: Says node_id is a top-level setting; it belongs in the storage "raft" stanza. [defects, defects #236237]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-18105c2af7
Admin handbook: Calls node_id a top-level line. [defects, defects #236238]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-d724d6077a
Database handbook: Places cluster_addr and node_id in the listener stanza. [defects, defects #236239]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-db82f8a365
API guide: Places cluster_addr in the listener stanza. [defects, defects #236240]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-16229dae9f
API guide: Lists api_addr as a listener setting, contradicting the sentences that say it is ignored there. [defects, defects #236241]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-2e982fd867
Admin handbook: Says a snapshot can be saved while sealed. [defects, defects #236242]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-534a353693
Admin handbook: Says the snapshot is removed when the container stops; it is lost only when the container is removed. [defects, defects #236243]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-ba76c1ef6d
Admin handbook: Attributes the uid-999 volume to the v2.5.5 releases, which never persisted data. [defects, defects #236244]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-9428b4e4ba
Admin handbook: Says the r1 volume is owned by UID 100 (it is 999), contradicting ADMIN_HANDBOOK.md:3219 and 3260. [defects, defects #236245]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-58f8602b36
Admin handbook: Says the server reads no environment variables, contradicting the dev-server instructions. [defects, defects #236246]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-a9b929e807
Admin handbook: Says mode 600 works for a mounted configuration file. [defects, defects #236247]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-738600d986
Admin handbook: Says the dev server needs no token header; requests need X-Vault-Token. [defects, defects #236248]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-fbea961737
Admin handbook: Says omitting the configuration mount makes the server exit with 'permission denied'. [defects, defects #236249]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-b51dd78e50
Admin handbook: Quotes an error message Docker does not print. [defects, defects #236250]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-940c953f79
Admin handbook: Says 'initialized and sealed' where 'unsealed' is meant; a sealed server answers 503. [defects, defects #236251]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-aed5c42cc5
Admin handbook: Calls :ro required; the server does not need it. [defects, defects #236252]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-a84a1fbd00
Admin handbook: The 'Reading a secret' example requests /v1/sys/mounts instead of the secret. [defects, defects #236253]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-780a0b9e1e
Admin handbook: The API write example and the 'same secret' CLI example address different secrets. [defects, defects #236254]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-2241df8704
Admin handbook: Says secrets enable prints no output. [defects, defects #236255]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-e9782ab7f5
Admin handbook: Says secrets enable prints no output. [defects, defects #236256]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-031e110bed
API guide: Says writing the path again undeletes a soft-deleted version; only `bao kv undelete` does. [defects, defects #236257]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-d66dbe7735
API guide: Presents GET /v1/sys/mounts as the API for listing secrets. [defects, defects #236258]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-52d2a3473b
API guide: Implies OTP generation needs no token; it returns 403. [defects, defects #236259]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-4c79200e04
API guide: Claims PUT /v1/sys/generate-root/attempt returns 403 for a token without policy; it returns 405. [defects, defects #236260]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-05a7ce2a2b
API guide: Quotes output that bao does not print. [defects, defects #236261]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-8fe1b1eebb
API guide: Describes copying the configuration into the container and shows commands that unseal before the restart that re-seals. [defects, defects #236262]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-98816ece27
Database handbook: Says the container filesystem is read-only and that data without a volume is lost when the container is stopped (it is writable and lost only on removal). [defects, defects #236263]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-ca7de3ce22
Database handbook: The shell example omits -it, so it does not open an interactive shell. [defects, defects #236264]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-86b700f546
Database handbook: Lists generate-root -status among commands that work without a token; it returns 403. [defects, defects #236265]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-733dc79e62
Database handbook: Says the health check stays unhealthy without the IP SAN; the -k probe does not verify the certificate. [defects, defects #236266]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-ce1ed5661d
Docker Hub README: Calls the build kit free while the bundle manifest prices it at 1000 cents and marks the release not free. [defects, defects #236267]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-f3b1fd4432
Docker Hub README: Calls the build kit a free download; the manifest prices it. [defects, defects #236268]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-aa04861fab
Admin handbook: The first uid-fix in the 'Upgrading' section (the round-1/round-2 critical's class) tells the customer to chown a placeholder host path; for the documented named volume there is no such path, so the… [defects, defects #243111]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-e0ba0c93d0
Admin handbook: Procedure as written is impossible (restart with added mount option); a customer who follows the restart leaves the server down with the TLS certificate error. [defects, defects #243112]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-64a2ab5421
Admin handbook: The API write example and the 'same secret' CLI example address different secrets (secret/secret/app vs secret/app); the text patches this with a parenthetical instead of fixing the command. [defects, defects #243113]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-f5447d825a
Admin handbook: Under 'Reading a secret' an unlabeled second curl requests /v1/sys/mounts and the paragraph describes mounts, which reads as the example for reading a secret. [defects, defects #243114]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-c03e7c52b1
Admin handbook: Garbled sentence: it names seal-status as the health endpoint without its query parameters, which are different endpoints with different status codes. [defects, defects #243115]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-a1856e9346
Admin handbook: 'or earlier release' attributes a uid-999 volume to releases (v2.5.5) that never persisted data, contradicting the v2.5.5 subsection. [defects, defects #243116]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-6df52b786f
Admin handbook: Says the volume's data is lost if the container is removed without a backup; the volume survives `docker rm`, as the handbook states elsewhere. [defects, defects #243117]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-5f79f2b2cc
Admin handbook: Quotes an error message the server does not print. [defects, defects #243118]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-c967396976
Admin handbook: After re-creating a container on the existing openbao-data volume the doc says it starts uninitialized; it starts initialized and sealed (contradicting ADMIN 3145). [defects, defects #243119]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-379e0ea928
Admin handbook: Prose sentence placed inside a command code block; the block cannot be run as written. [defects, defects #243120]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-c110c8c386
Admin handbook: Dangling sentence with no antecedent that reads as if the dev server fails. [defects, defects #243121]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-05fb41b438
Database handbook: Lists `bao operator unseal` as a command that needs a token, contradicting the sentences that say unsealing requires only the keys. [defects, defects #243122]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-98b414aab8
Database handbook: Example of running a program with docker exec shows a hot tar of the live data directory as a backup, contradicting the handbook's offline-only tar backup procedure. [defects, defects #243123]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-4bc4a8bb18
Admin handbook: Ran the image with a config holding exactly this listener stanza (cluster_addr inside listener, none at top level): log "[WARN] unknown or unsupported field cluster_addr found in configuration at… [defects, defects #249524]
highfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-667687f241
Admin handbook: ADMIN_HANDBOOK.md 1769-1776: under "Reading a secret" an unlabeled code block runs `curl ... [defects, defects #249525]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-5e3bc981da
API guide: API guide 1462-1468: the "Secret Listing" section introduces "The API endpoint:" followed by a block with `GET /v1/sys/mounts`, and only afterwards says it lists engines, not secrets. [defects, defects #249526]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-0a2016b37c
Admin handbook: Dev server: kv put x=1, x=2; kv delete -versions=1 secret/a; kv get -version=1 secret/a prints only Metadata (deletion_time set) and no Data section, i.e. [defects, defects #249527]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-0f919280ea
Database handbook: Same reproduction: `bao kv get -version=1 secret/a` after `kv delete -versions=1` returns metadata with deletion_time and no key/value data. [defects, defects #249528]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-087bcd5b9f
API guide: Created a token whose policy is only path "secret/data/*" {create,read,update}: `bao kv get secret/app` works, `bao kv metadata get secret/app` -> GET /v1/secret/metadata/app Code: 403. [defects, defects #249529]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-1763330b3b
API guide: curl with no token, with token "nope" and with a valid token whose policy lacks the path all return {"errors":["permission denied"]} [403] (the limited token: "1 error occurred: * permission… [defects, defects #249530]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-3530de9c73
API guide: Same reproduction as the item at line 1015: no token, invalid token and insufficient policy all return the identical body. [defects, defects #249531]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-ee6c54b477
Database handbook: The sentence before it says the new container "comes back initialized and sealed"; `bao operator init` on it returns HTTP 400 "Vault is already initialized" (run live). [defects, defects #249532]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-99fbd930ea
Database handbook: The file is mounted :ro in the container and the image has no sed, vi or shell editor (provenance/IMAGE_BINARIES.txt), so it cannot be modified with docker exec; the host edit + docker restart path… [defects, defects #249533]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-c4faaa3e61
Database handbook: docker exec runs the program given and ignores the entrypoint (ADMIN_HANDBOOK.md 3717 says so; the command below the sentence itself names `bao`). [defects, defects #249534]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-5120437e14
Database handbook: Uninitialized server: curl /v1/secret/data/app and /v1/sys/mounts -> {"errors":["Vault is sealed"]} [503]; only sys/health answers 501. [defects, defects #249535]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-45317ed790
Admin handbook: Root token recovery (generate-root) needs the unseal keys in every procedure (nonce step takes an unseal key); it cannot help when the keys are lost. [defects, defects #249536]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-2a4e084649
Admin handbook: Unseal keys are printed once by `bao operator init` and are not stored on the server (ADMIN 443/764: "shown only once"); the data directory does not hold "unsealed keys". [defects, defects #249537]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-2feb7af57c
API guide: API guide 2982-2988: the code block lists `bao operator unseal` before `docker restart openbao`; a restart re-seals the server (observed Sealed true after docker restart), so a customer following… [defects, defects #249538]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-cc8035be56
Admin handbook: Root Token Recovery "Without any valid token": the re-created container uses the shipped plain-HTTP listener, and this first curl (and the update curl below it) use https:// with no certificate:… [defects, defects #249539]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-5a7858a107
Database handbook: docker run --rm IMAGE operator init -> `Get "http://127.0.0.1:8200/v1/sys/seal-status": dial tcp 127.0.0.1:8200: connect: connection refused`; the example cannot initialize anything. [defects, defects #249540]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-e558c00cc7
Database handbook: Same reproduction (connection refused on 127.0.0.1:8200). [defects, defects #249541]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-90bd3dd9b1
Admin handbook: validation/test-results.json records 3 requests (GET sys/health, sys/seal-status, secret/data/rs against a -dev container); the API guide section "Requests verified against this release" lists only… [defects, defects #249542]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-28dcddfec9
Database handbook: Same: only 3 requests are recorded as verified (validation/test-results.json, API guide 4531). [defects, defects #249543]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-7af94ee9fb
Admin handbook: The list under this sentence has two bullets (GET /v1/sys/health, GET /v1/sys/seal-status); the CLI `bao status` that follows is not an endpoint. [defects, defects #250196]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-a520e69131
Database handbook: The curl blocks at DB_HANDBOOK.md:962/968 use https://127.0.0.1:8200 with --cacert tls/bao.crt and nothing says they apply only to a TLS listener; the shipped listener is plain HTTP (openbao.hcl… [defects, defects #250197]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—
RSD-openbao-be8686901e
Admin handbook: ADMIN_HANDBOOK.md:725 and 731 give only the https/--cacert form; the shipped listener is plain HTTP, where https fails with curl: (35) wrong version number. [defects, defects #250198]
lowfixed-before-releaseheld review (review model)—

Verification

1 item not recorded
  • Reproduced before publishingyes (rebuilt digest sha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8 · published digest sha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8 · digest match yes · builder moby/buildkit:v0.31.2 · build seconds 288) [docs/provenance/REPRO_VERIFICATION.json, verified]
  • Final contract gate (G8)PASS (checks artifact_coverage, assetchain_coverage, cosign, cpu_baseline, offline_rebuild, rebuild_manifest, scan_grade, scout_grade_a, script_copies, tag_base_os, thread_exit, trademark_shipped, unpack_files, upgrade_check, vex_shipped) [g8_result.json, result]
  • Grade at releaseA (percent 94 · tool docker scout policy 1.26.0 · config docker-default · org vex no · at 2026-11-17T10:07:17Z · failing Docker Scout counts 10 packages with copyleft licences (GPL, LGPL, MPL), all of them operating-system packages (it counts only packages whose licence it can read; the SBOM lists every component).) [SCOUT_EVIDENCE.json, docker_scout_policy]
  • Image signatureverified on the index and the linux/amd64 manifest (key fingerprint 04daa92344a52dbc · at 2026-11-17T10:07:02Z) [docs/provenance/IMAGE_EVIDENCE.json, signed]
  • Image signature transparency-log entries [deliverables/provenance/PROMOTION_RECORD.json, sign_stdout_tail]
  • rebuild.json signatureSigstore bundle, release key (key fingerprint 04daa92344a52dbc · log index 3945056008 · transparency-log entry · integrated 2026-11-17T10:11:51Z) [ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.json.sigstore, verificationMaterial.tlogEntries[0]]
  • Signed attestations
    • kind provenance · digest sha256:0da03bca01630f3a873f872b439d3b85384ac032b25eb6208163b811f0c91a4e · state attached · log index 3945056645 · transparency-log entry
    • kind sbom · digest sha256:0da03bca01630f3a873f872b439d3b85384ac032b25eb6208163b811f0c91a4e · state attached · log index 3945057174 · transparency-log entry
    • kind vsa · digest sha256:0da03bca01630f3a873f872b439d3b85384ac032b25eb6208163b811f0c91a4e · state attached · log index 3945057963 · transparency-log entry
    • kind provenance · digest sha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8 · state attached · log index 3945058495 · transparency-log entry
    • kind sbom · digest sha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8 · state attached · log index 3945059169 · transparency-log entry
    • kind vsa · digest sha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8 · state attached · log index 3945059882 · transparency-log entry
    (at 2026-11-17T10:11:51Z) [attestations.json, results]
  • Pins recorddocs/PINS.md and docs/provenance/PINS.json in the archive (https://readystack.dev/products/openbao/recipe) [docs/provenance/PINS.json]

Offline clean-room rebuilds

  • 2026-11-10T22:15:56Z on build host 3 (Docker-in-Docker daemon with --network none): bit for bit yes, digest match yes, customer verify yes
    rebuilt sha256:76414b62b7ae174c87229c86250a37ccadc885d2fc1f78a08397f4d820578cad [clean-room rebuild ledger, runs[733]]
  • 2026-11-17T09:49:21Z on build host 4 (Docker-in-Docker daemon with --network none): bit for bit yes, digest match yes, customer verify yes
    rebuilt sha256:9e807f8537e45aa79ee7ffc61e803c126410eef7a5ed63efaf8c039184ade2a8 [clean-room rebuild ledger, runs[876]]
  • Not recorded: the policy tool's --result-file itself (its per-policy results are copied into SCOUT_EVIDENCE.json and the archive's IMAGE_EVIDENCE.json; the file is not kept)

Publication

Fully recorded 1 pending at generation
  • Image pushed (internal tag), publish_image passed2026-11-17T09:37:23Z [stage_runs, stage_runs chain 931 stage publish_image]
  • Archive manifests written2026-11-17T10:09:35Z [PUBLISH_MANIFEST.json, published_at]
  • Pending at generation: the archive cut-over on prodasset, the release tag's promotion and the site event (this trail was generated after G8 and before them; they are appended as a 'publication' event in History)

Packages and CPU level

Fully recorded
  • x86-64 level the image needsv1 (used v4 · baseline v2 · elf files 62 · probed 2026-11-09T16:34:16Z · source build_kit) [release_images, isa_level_hard]

History

2 events
  • 2026-11-17T10:13:19Z generated: by KitForge release/build_trail.py · generator commit 0d45789790ee5eae253389c3c7f6ba99862b797b
  • 2026-11-17T10:14:56Z publication: promoted at 2026-11-17T10:13:59Z · promoted digest sha256:0da03bca01630f3a873f872b439d3b85384ac032b25eb6208163b811f0c91a4e · promotion method imagetools_create_retag_by_digest_no_rebuild · site event 574 · checklist status complete · checklist at 2026-11-17T10:14:56Z · record workspace: deliverables/provenance/PROMOTION_RECORD.json, RELEASE_CHECKLIST.json

Records

25 records
RecordWhere it isRows
docs/defects/defects.jsoninside the archive (ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz)—
docs/provenance/IMAGE_EVIDENCE.jsoninside the archive (ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz)—
docs/provenance/LOCKED_DIGEST.txtinside the archive (ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz)—
docs/provenance/PINS.jsoninside the archive (ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz)—
docs/provenance/REPRO_VERIFICATION.jsoninside the archive (ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz)—
docs/provenance/SOURCE_TREE_HASH.jsoninside the archive (ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.tar.gz)—
MANIFEST.jsonbeside the archive (prodasset /data/production/openbao/v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4/), as staged for publishing—
PUBLISH_MANIFEST.jsonbeside the archive (prodasset /data/production/openbao/v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4/), as staged for publishing—
ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.jsonbeside the archive (prodasset /data/production/openbao/v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4/), as staged for publishing—
ReadyStack-openbao-v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4.rebuild.json.sigstorebeside the archive (prodasset /data/production/openbao/v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4/), as staged for publishing—
SCOUT_EVIDENCE.jsonbeside the archive (prodasset /data/production/openbao/v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4/), as staged for publishing—
clean-room rebuild ledgerthe clean-room rebuild ledger (runstate/audit-2026-09/bit4bit.json, not published)—
build_requestssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)606
chainssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)931
defectssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)openbao v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4
drive_runssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)chain 931
held_roundssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)chain 931
lesson_recallssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)chain 931
micro_step_runssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)chain 931
release_imagessadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)openbao v2.7.2-CE-ubuntu24.04-r4
stage_eventssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)chain 931
stage_runssadb, ReadyStack's engine database (not published)chain 931
attestations.jsonthe chain's workspace on the controller (not published)—
deliverables/provenance/PROMOTION_RECORD.jsonthe chain's workspace on the controller (not published)—
g8_result.jsonthe chain's workspace on the controller (not published)—